Products
Genealogy Books
Genealogy Software

Information
Payment Methods
Shipping
Safe Shopping

Genealogy Websites
US Genealogy
Surnames
Canadian Genealogy
Free Family Tree Website






Spotlight customer reviews:
Customer Rating: Average rating of 3/5Average rating of 3/5Average rating of 3/5Average rating of 3/5Average rating of 3/5
Summary: what a long way we have come
Comment: Before I am pilloried as a heathen and burned in effigy as a barbarian, let me begin by saying yes,
I recognize the importance of this book - historical objectivity and attributing events to human
causes are the foundations of the discipline of history, and we owe that to Thucydides (and, to a
lesser extent, Herodotus.)

With that said, I was disappointed at how laborious I found this
book. To its credit, it was exhaustive in its approach to the subject matter, beginning with the
geographical layout of the Pelopnnesus and its subsequent political development in the distant past
prior to the war. And the causes of the war were certainly discussed objectively. But the book was
dry - really dry. The sort of thing that college students, in their worst nightmares, have of what
a history class is like dry. With all due respect to Thucydides, it read like a monontone
lecture.

Is there valuable information here? Absolutely. Is it a landmark piece of history?
Without doubt. But we have (thankfully) come a long way from the monotonous drone in history
writing since the 4th century BC. In other words, its important, but a very tough read.


Customer Rating: Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5
Summary: Excellent Ancient History: International Affairs
Comment: Thucydides is one of the great historians of antiquity. He offers a first hand account of the
terrible Peloponnesian war that plagued Greece for over thirty-years. Not only does he discuss the
war between Athens and Sparta, but also he gives a very informative description of Greek life and
history leading up to the war.

Thucydides discusses the early war with the Persians and the
subsequent power-vacuum left in Greece following the conclusion of the conflict. He discusses the
merits of both the Athenian League and their Spartan counter parts, thus remaining objective even
though having served as an Athenian general. His knowledge of battles is profound, but more
interesting is his discussion on the politics of Greece at the time.

He makes great use of
political dialogues in order to emphasize important aspects of the conflict and the Grecian
political situation. Especially interesting are Pericles' funeral oration, and the Melian dialogue.
Both dialogues deal with matters of state, i.e. the good citizen, and realist thought towards
nationalist interest.

Through Thucydides work we are able to draw numerous parallels from
antiquity to modern times. Thucydides has almost perfectly captured current international politics
on miniature scale, making observation and study most beneficial to those interested in learning the
underlying processes of global affairs. I recommend a close reading of The Peloponnesian War for
any student of political science or for anyone interested in Ancient History. A most fascinating
read.


Customer Rating: Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5
Summary: Not as good as Herodotus, but good enough
Comment: This was a very interesting and easy book to read concerning this ancient 30-year Greek civil war
that was so devastating to the whole of Hellas. Too bad the author dies before being able to
complete the work. Reading this made me think how US politicians and rhetoreticians pay lip service
to Athenian democracy while in fact this democracy was very different from US democracy and was a
democracy that only included Athenian male citizens while women were excluded. Athenian democracy
also supported slavery and was abusive to its subject states. Reading this book one learns that the
Athenians were the bad guys and that Pericles was a leader who looked out for his peoples interests
while disregarding other peoples well being.

Customer Rating: Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5
Summary: Greek social and war history, the human condition & nature
Comment: Thucydides, half a generation after the "father of history" Herodotus, is an amazing, analytical,
concise (though side tracking) trip through one of the most interesting ancient wars.

Historical
arguments run as to the exact order that the text should be presented in, but this appears to be the
excepted norm. A thoughtful and deep look into the war that tore apart the ancient Greek world,
this is the original "Clash of the Titans."

Thucydides employs the use of rhetorical and artistic
forms to put forth major speeches and to give us a glimps into selected sections and minor
scirmishes that led to the war between Athens and Sparta.

Rather than the traditional Homeric
theory that Wars happened because of the actions of a few people in high places, Thucy. looks to
larger social and international reasoning. There is no "it's because of the gods," but instead a
deep look at human nature and the way that we behave.

A general in the war, and later this
historian and writer, Thucy. looks at the human condition logically and uses a medical perspective
to break things down as if war, and even human nature were a disease that we have yet to cure. This
is genius.

He begins with the theory that the only important things are: men, money and ships.
This returns again and again throughout the entire work until we see how ironical this statement
was, and that he has been slowly dragging us along to follow his theories.

Wonderfully writen and
amazingly ahead of its time, this history should be on everyone's shelf; after they have read it at
least once.


Customer Rating: Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5
Summary: The Original Man-On-The-Spot
Comment: Thucydides fought in the Peloponnesian War and probably attended some of the parliamentary debates
in Athens which he so faithfully chronicles. His accounts of the diplomatic manoevring over
Corcyria, his narrative of the breakdown of social order, and Pericles funeral oration are immortal.
Together with Herodotus, this forms the sourcebook for the critical events of ancient Greek military
history. On a whim, however, I have docked the classic master one star, on the utterly prosaic
grounds that old Thu's account doesn't actually cover ALL of what is now known as the Peloponnesian
War, not only omitting some of the lead-up events but also leaving the reader dangling in suspense
at the end. One might think this prosaic, but then again of all the ancient writers, Thucydides was
the most prosaic, so I'm sure he wouldn't begrudge this.




Showing page 7 of 10
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 

Genealogy Books Copyright 2005-2006 Genealogy Books. All rights reserved.